Does 1 Corinthians 11. 1-16 deal with matters of culture?

Howard Coles, Coleford, England

Precious Seed

An overseas enquirer recently wrote in with the following comment, ‘I believe that 1 Corinthians chapter 11 verses 1 to 16 is a cultural passage and is not necessarily relevant to many cultures today’.

In answering this commonly held view on these verses it is worthwhile referring to the four ‘timeless’ things clearly evident in the passage, namely:

  1. Headship - ‘But I would have you know, that the head of every man is Christ; and the head of the woman is the man; and the head of Christ is God’, v. 3. What is referred to in this verse is the order of ‘the headships’. The term ‘headship conveys metaphorically the authority, order or pre-eminence in relationship that exists on account, not necessarily of superiority, but of priority in function. As it cannot be other than plainly evident that God is still the head of Christ, this is a timeless statement and not just for the generation to which it was first written. It therefore follows that the rest of the verse must also be timeless. To say otherwise renders it meaningless.
  2. Creation - ‘For the man is not of the woman; but the woman of the man. Neither was the man created for the woman; but the woman for the man’, vv. 8-9. The order of creation cannot be changed, so therefore that which is drawn from this unchangeable order in the creation of the man and the woman must make the truth again something which is timeless and therefore relevant to all ages and cultures.
  3. Angels - ‘For this cause ought the woman to have power on her head because of the angels’, v. 10. The question could be asked ‘Did the angels only look down upon the believers gathered at Corinth?’ The answer must surely be that they have continued to observe what is being practised in every local church through the ages to the churches currently functioning in the world today.
  4. Nature - ‘Doth not even nature itself teach you, that if a man have long hair, it is a shame unto him?’, v. 14. The Holy Spirit here draws upon the order of ‘nature itself’ so understandably this order cannot possibly be something that was culturally produced. It must then be a timeless thing applicable to every age.

So by these four timeless things we understand that this passage must apply to today as much as it did when first written. It cannot be dismissed as merely ‘cultural’, or ‘geographical’, applying to the saints at Corinth alone. Indeed the statement of verse 16, ‘But if any man seem to be contentious, we have no such custom, neither the churches of God’, plainly shows that the truth taught, applied to all the local churches then existing and was something the apostle held as a continuing practice for all time.

Clearly there are scriptures where culture is involved and in which we have the option to substitute our own parallel practices in their place. For instance, ‘Greet one another with an holy kiss’, 2 Cor. 13. 12. In the United Kingdom the usual form of greeting between men, is with a handshake and not by kissing. In this scripture then there is no underlying principle of doctrine at stake and we can choose to defer from the practice being taught accepting that it is something that can be taken culturally.

Some would dismiss these verses in 1 Corinthians 11 as being nonfundamental and therefore something that we need not to be too concerned about. However could there be anything more fundamental than our subjection in love to the Lord Jesus and our obedience to His word? These matters have to do with the honour and place that the Lord Jesus has amongst His own people and we cannot just dismiss them as peripheral or of little consequence. What a privilege it is for us as believers today as we gather, to demonstrate that Christ is the Head of the church and so to cover that which is for the glory of man, that His glory alone should be pre-eminent.

There are 22 articles in
ISSUE (2005, Volume 60 Issue 1)

The Central Role of the King

Contemporary Praise and Worship

Cumbria Gospel Outreach

Does 1 Corinthians 11. 1-16 deal with matters of culture?

Editorial

The Fruit of the Spirit is Love

What does God know?

The God rich in Mercy

Gospel Work and Other Activities

Great Truths of the Bible

Kingfisher christian camp trust

What isLove?

The Message of the book of Daniel

On-Line Bible version 1.41

The Record of a Family Tragedy

Schools Outreach in Northamptonshire

Seymour Gospel Hall

Studies in 2 Thessalonians

Timeless truths about the local assembly

DestructiveTsunami in India

The 1904Welsh revival

Wise words from the book of Proverbs

This article is not part of a series

There are 47 articles by this author

Do Angels Have Any Relevance To Believers In The Present Age?

I HaveSeveral Questions Arising Out Of Malcolm Horlock’s First Article On 1 Corinthians 14

Are Demons Active Today?

How Does A Christian Deal With Feelings Of Guilt?

How Can I Know the Will of God for My Life?

Is it right for a Christian to drink alcohol?

What do we do if another Christian wrongs us?

How can a young Christian begin to witness for the Lord?

Kingfisher christian camp trust

Does 1 Corinthians 11. 1-16 deal with matters of culture?

Does the Bible teach that there’s a place, or state of existence, called Purgatory?

Christ - Is He not omniscient, all knowing?

Is it acceptable for a Christian to take part in lotteries or other forms of gambling?

How do I deal with temptation in my Christian life?

What is the difference between praise and worship?

Where did evil originate?

How could Christ increase in wisdom and stature, Luke 2. 52?

Is attendance at the meetings of the local assembly essential or optional?

What about Letters of Commendation?

Does intelligent extraterrestrial life exist? and Will God allow man to settle on other worlds?

Is it the fault of Christian parents that their children do not become Christians?

Why doesn’t the Bible tell us exactly when the Lord will return?

Should believers celebrate Christmas?

Should young christian families move to an assembly where there are other young people?

How should a believer deal with depression?

What should be the Christian’s attitude toward Muslims

Why does God allow suffering?

Does God appoint the rulers of this world and does He control their decisions?

Can very young children be saved?

Honesty - Does Truth Matter?

What does the Bible say about same-sex marriage?

What happens to a christian when they die?

Four ‘Yea Lord’s’ in the Gospels

Question Time

Gold and the Glories of the Lord Jesus

Thoughts on the Love of God

Vision for Outreach

Man and the Gospel

How Long

Question: Is it good for us to prepare for the Lord’s supper?

The Christian and the World

The Coming of the Son of Man

The Gospel Yesterday and Today

Question Time

Thoughts on ‘The Disciples’ Prayer’ and the Temptation of the Lord Jesus in the Wi

The King James Version and Principles of Translation - Part 1

The King James Version and Principles of Translation - Part 2